Transcript 0:00 Welcome everyone to a new episode of the FinOps Weekly Podcast. 0:03 And today we are going to talk about TBM, this concept that has been related to, to FinOps, and we had, uh, several comments on social media on what it is and, you know, explaining a bit the connection of, of it to, to FinOps. 0:16 And to bring some light into it, we have, uh, Nilofer with us. How are you, Nilofer? Um, I'm good, Victor. Thank you. Hope you're well too. And also, of course, uh, Damian. Damian, how are you? 0:31 I'm doing great, thank you. Thank you, Nilofer, for joining us. Uh, great day today. Yeah. It's going to be, uh, an interesting conversation because when, uh... I can, you know, break a lot of, of context. 0:43 When I joined, uh, the FinOps ecosystem and started to, to learn about it, uh, we come about this concept of TBM. 0:49 I, I saw there was references, a lot of, you know, uh, reference to multiple, uh, topics, but then was ITAM, ITSM, and then was TBM. And for me, TBM, I, I wasn't very sure about what, what it is. 1:02 And today probably for people that are starting and are not very familiar into this topic, uh, we want to bring some light about what it is, how it relates to FinOps, and how it can be important for your practice. 1:12 So, uh, Nilofer, uh, just starting with the basic question for, for the audience, what is, uh, TBM so we can explain to, to the audience? 1:22 Uh, TBM, Technology Business Management, is a discipline, uh, where your, uh, IT spend can be governed in both aspects. So A, running a business and B, changing a business. 1:34 So when you run the business, it's important that your IT spend is in alignment with the business outcome that you want to bring. Um, at the same time, it is also, um, it, it also gives you 1:48 the, uh, the, um, bus-business, uh, it also gives you bus- it, it also gives your business the ability, uh, to change. So for example, keeping up with the innovation, um, bringing enterprise agility. 1:59 So both these aspect, running the business and changing the business, um, uh, in, in light of IT spend is the framework called TBM, Technology Business Management. Brilliant framework. I'm huge fan of, uh, TBM actually. 2:13 Uh, and, and specifically is, um, is around that, uh, every spend in IT has to bring business value. In olden days, uh, IT used to be a cost center, not like a strategic partner for business. Mm-hmm. 2:28 In past twenty thir- thirty years, the change what we have seen is that most company are technology company, they're technology focused. 2:35 So IT is not just as in the support function, uh, but to bring more innovation in your products. To, to, uh... 2:42 If you are like, for example, a retail company, making sure that you are reaching far more geography better, uh, your customer experience is better. 2:49 All this is, uh, all this we can achieve only when you have a, a robust, uh, uh, IT strategy in place with a strong budget. And to, to govern this budget, uh, this, uh, TBM framework came to, to existence. 3:05 Oh, uh, th-thanks for, for that, uh, thoughtful explanation. I think now it's very, uh, more, more interactive. 3:12 So you, you need to understand that, you know, it's connected to, to the business, and you need to now is to move the IT spend and the IT, uh, consumption to, uh, business relevant metrics. 3:24 And there is a framework, uh, by the TBM Council, if I'm not mistaken, uh, that handles all of that. And you can... I, I'll probably leave the link in the description about. 3:32 So you can check it, all the taxonomy, all the stuff that has been updated, uh, recently. I, I wanted to add a something. I think, I... First of all, I met, uh, Nilofer in the FinOps X as well. We met, it was great. 3:45 I, I, if I remember correctly that, uh, JR said that, uh, uh, or, or there was a lot of talks about, uh, that the FinOps needs to be best friends with the TBM or something like that. 3:57 Um, I don't remember if JR has said this or not, but I fully agree with the statement that FinOps and TBM should be best friends. [laughs] One, uh, uh, is, uh, when we talk about FinOps, it's mainly around cloud FinOps. 4:09 So it's about, um, uh, variable spending of cloud, uh, on... We are talking about hyperscaler. If you are not careful, in one day your spend could go up to a million dollar, and we won't be surprised by that, right? 4:23 Um, and, and then TBM is there to govern your IT spend, so it has to work hand in hand. And yes, they have to be best friends. So I, I agree with this statement, and I like this statement actually now. 4:34 [laughs] Thank you. [laughs] It was absolute pleasure, uh, meeting you in FinOps X Barcelon- uh, FinOps X in, uh, San Diego. Yeah. Good deal. Good deal. 4:44 And, you know, talking about the, the synergies and, and the synergies between FinOps and TBM. 4:50 So for someone that doesn't or maybe it's in the FinOps practice that is more, uh, you know, used to it, how, uh, or which synergies do you think are between FinOps and TBM, and where do you think that is starting to connect, let's say? 5:06 Uh, which points the, do the connection be easier than, than others? Um, okay, so the way I see it is more, uh, like TBM is more a top-down sort of discipline- Mm-hmm... 5:21 uh, where, uh, it's, it's very strategic, uh, where the, where your C-level would already make a decision on going for, let's say, uh, like particular ERP system, right? 5:32 Um, and FinOps is more like a bottom-up sort of discipline, so where the engineers are in charge or, well, engineer has ability to write couple of line of code and spend your company's money. 5:44 So it, it is, um, it kind of meets in the middle, I would say, uh, where, uh, a strategic, um, a strategic IT decision has to be communicated well to engineers. 5:57 And, and then it would enable engineers to make the right decisions, uh, for the organization. So I, I guess it, it kind of meets in, in the middle, uh, when on the execution layer side of it.Okay. Good deal. 6:14 So you-- So for example, just connecting the, the topics, maybe when, uh, the unit economics and all this business value related are getting information from, uh, the billing and from all this granular data from, from cloud or from any other provider, 6:32 is that where it connects to, to TBM? Um, it, it, it kind of does. Uh, because, see, TBM would have different, um, cost centers, right? So it can be internal labor, external labor. 6:47 It could be about different hardware, software costs, right? These are all different cost pools, uh, that would align and make different cost towers. 6:56 So, uh, and the cost tower when we talk about is the application layer. It's about the data center cost, about the delivery. It's about, um, new application deployment or the IT management, stuff like that. 7:07 That would be different cost towers, and that cost towers would create different solutions for business. And at the end, on, on top of the solution, it's business value. 7:16 So that's how the whole TBM framework, uh, or I would say the TBM structure is. Um, and for FinOps, it's, um, uh, FinOps is a part of TBM, if I'm, uh, if I say it correctly. 7:31 So for example, if it's any hardware cost, any infrastructure cost, that's a cost pool or, sorry, a cost center, uh, in TBM, which would align to different solutions and bring the business value. 7:43 But at the end, it's an infrastructure cost of cloud, which is a, uh, which is a cost, uh, which would come under cost pool of TBM framework. Okay. 7:54 I, I guess now that another synergy that we can, uh, talk about or add to that is, you know, now that the focus is, uh, 8:03 trying to reach another area like SaaS and like, you know, the data centers, maybe that's another key area in which, you know, uh, they can collaborate and, and, and basically, uh, help the business in, you know, wh-while presenting or providing insights. 8:19 And, and of course, after you implement the, the, the focus, uh, uh, standard into the, the data centers, then I guess that you would create interesting dashboards and see how all the IT operation and kind of like separated between the infrastructure, the cloud and, and stuff like that. 8:42 Yeah. A hundred percent. A hundred percent. 8:45 Uh, because at the e- at the end of the day, look, both the, both the discipline, the objective is to make sure that, uh, the spend of IT is very strategic, and the stre- spend of IT should bring business value. 8:57 Um, but how is that? That's when we come in place, right? That's where we, we have to bring that sort of visibility to business. And, and Victor, what you touched upon earlier about the unit economics, right? 9:09 Uh, sometimes in FinOps, it's, it's easier to calculate unit economics when you're just... when you're talking about the storage cost, compute cost, right? 9:17 Uh, but when you talk about business side of the unit economics, that would differ from, from each business, each industry you are in. 9:24 Whether you are oil and gas industry, probably you would look-- want to look at some different, uh, sort of cost metrics. 9:30 Uh, when you are in retail, when you're in e-commerce, when you're a SaaS company, then you probably want to look at the different unit economics, which would be more in alignment with business. 9:41 So that would also have an aspect of TBM, uh, embedded. TBM, uh, like labor cost, for example, fixed labor costs. Mm-hmm. 9:49 Your FTEs or your contractors or the third-party providers what you're using, that should also be considered when you're talking about TBM unit metrics. So there, there's a very strong synergy, uh, strong alignment. 10:02 And again, there, there's another topic we could touch on here is, like, um, scope of FinOps, right? Because now when you talk about licensing cost or data center cost, previously it was just part of TBM. 10:13 Now in FinOps, because we are expanding, we are in the cloud plus era of FinOps, then there's very strong alignment, um, a good overlap and a good synergy, um, I would say, uh, has to be there in, in both disciplines. 10:28 So, so I, uh, and, um, I mean, I particularly, in my opinion, I feel that it's, um, uh, it's the best way to govern your IT cost holistically. 10:38 Uh, uh, if you're just looking at FinOps and cloud spend, probably you're missing out the bigger picture. If you're looking at TBM but not considering variable cost of cloud, then again you're missing out. 10:47 So, uh, it, it has to, uh, like the businesses and the C-level, the leaders has to, uh, s- to have an... keep an open eye for both the framework in, um, uh, i- in a synergetic way. Okay. 11:03 So yeah, having both, uh, applied I think are the best solution, especially for large, uh, companies that foresee or have large decisions and more strategic decision to make. 11:13 You can leverage the TBM for the generics, and then you leverage FinOps for like the down-to-earth calculations and the real, uh, you know, numbers that are there, such as, you know, um, the co-- as you mentioned, the unit economics are very varied based on the sector. 11:29 Like you don't measure, I don't know, uh, revenue per shop in a retail market rather than, uh, or your website, uh, user revenue in a retail onl- in an e-commerce rather than in oil and gas that you may make, I don't know, the installation or how much time does it take the, the, the trading of the oil and the, and the resources. 11:50 It's, it's very different, the business. And, and it's good because it will make you understand better the company and the sector that you're working for. 11:58 And this is valuable for both work, for your career and in, for example, for financial decision. Like if you want to... 12:06 you like to invest and you want to research about a company, you probably better understand the, the sector. If you understand the sector, you probably understand where your company's-Great in getting better or not. 12:17 And with that, you may, uh, be able to get better in your career because at some point and at some levels, board levels, uh, C-levels especially, 12:28 all gets down to the numbers and to the sector numbers and to the metrics that drive the business. So that's also valuable. So unless... Like, apart... 12:38 If you are C-level or not C-level, that's valuable information [chuckles] that should-- you should be able to, to know. And talking about the, the sceneries and the, the... 12:47 This collision, or let's say this collision, this joinment in the, let's say, in the private cloud, in the data center cloud, especially now with the, um, data sovereign or the cloud sovereign, all these, you know, regional stuff that we are having. 13:02 How do you see especially FinOps and, and TBM, uh, being changed now? Because, you know, we come from the cloud. For the FinOps cloud, everything is cloud related. 13:12 But now we are moving to, you know, data center, regional stuff. Um, how do you see both TBM and FinOps working on that area of the, let's say, private cloud, the plus, uh, cloud side? Ye- uh, yeah. 13:28 So see, like I said, FinOps, um, uh, FinOps has expanded its scope, right? Like what you're mentioning that, um, uh, we were talking about earlier, that cloud plus era of FinOps. 13:40 Uh, whereas, uh, TBM already we're talking about fixed cost. Uh- Mm-hmm. So, so at this point, uh, it's not only about, um, applying FinOps principle to TBM, but applying TBM framework to FinOps as well. 13:56 So when going forward in this cloud plus era, uh, we'll have to go left and right, and right and left in both direction, uh, rather than, uh, just, um, uh, use... 14:09 I mean, I, I know we have, we have used, uh, FinOps', uh, phase like inform, um, operate, optimize, uh, cycle. Uh, but at this time, we'll have to consider different fixed, uh, cost element to, to this cycle. 14:25 Like for ex- uh, it- it's, uh, for, for this, um, uh, FinOps life- lifecycle, it works really well in cloud, but when it comes to data center and the fixed, uh, cost element to that, there will be, uh, there won't be much room for variation. 14:42 However, there will be plenty of room to understand that if, uh, the capacity, what we plan for a data center, is it fully optimized? Are we fully utilizing it, right? 14:53 So a utilization part of it would come in picture rather than optimization. 14:59 Because once you are in this and, uh, one- once you are in certain lease, again, depending on the agreement, depending on the size of the business, uh, you have this fixed cost, whether you're using it or not. 15:09 So you rather use it or use it in more strategic way and look at the whole picture, whole business picture, uh, to, to, to, uh, uh, utilize, uh, your capacity well. 15:21 So I guess utilization would, w- we'll have to start using that word more often in, [chuckles] in FinOps, uh, rather than just op- rather than focusing on optimization side of it. Yeah. 15:32 And I guess that when you have, like, the provision capacity, you need to now work on utilization. And, and moving about that, uh, because, you know, previously to cloud, uh, there was... 15:44 And one of the reasons that people move into cloud was, uh, the variety of- the variable, uh, moved of cloud. 15:51 So you can spin up, uh, instances, and you don't have to, let's say, uh, book or buy ser- uh, servers for a long time. 16:01 Do you think that after cloud, and now that we go to private, let's say a cloud plus system, do you think that that, um, contracts or that, uh, provisioning of infrastructure in private cloud will become more agile? 16:16 Like you would be able to, um, kind of use a cloud approach into your data center or being able to acquire, um, servers easily? 16:26 Because before it was like, I don't know, a five-year contract, and you can have that amount of resources, and you have a lot of wasted infrastructure because you need to provision for five years. Mm-hmm. 16:36 Uh, do you think that now after going to the cloud and maybe using a hybrid structure, there will be more agility in getting, uh, data center infrastructure? 16:44 I think so, and that's how businesses should mold themselves because the agility has to be there. And one beautiful thing about FinOp-- uh, the TBM framework is that it does talk about business agility. 16:54 When we talk about changing the business, it's about innovation in the business and having business agility. 16:59 So a data center, uh, should adopt in a way that, um, giving flexibility to, to their customers, uh, not having what you just mentioned, that a very long-term contract may not be that useful for probably startup, may not be useful given the volatile industr- uh, um, the volatile market what we are in. 17:21 There's, there's always change coming in, right? Uh, so having those, uh, long-term leases or fixed contract may not work in future. 17:30 Uh, and in future even like, uh, data centers or would al- would also adapt to, to public cloud sort of principle where, where you can open your account by using a credit card, which I don't, I don't think that should be a right way for enterprise. 17:45 [laughs] I'm not advocating for that. But what I'm saying is that, that, that level of agility, uh, what public cloud has, uh, probably private cloud, uh, should also start working on that. 17:55 Uh, to be honest, if you see like, um, uh, different private cloud providers like SAP, right? Uh, they, they are also changing. 18:04 Uh, you see, uh, rather than just focusing on enterprise level clients, now you see that SAP S/4HANA, uh, or their, um, uh, cloud domain has, um, or offering has changed significantly what it used to be five years ago, seven years ago and now. 18:20 I mean, I'm not even talking about twenty years ago, but even if in five to seven years you can see that level of change.Interesting. And, you know, uh, adding a bit more about that, do you think that because of the... 18:34 Talking about the point that I mentioned before, the regional side, you know, now that we are in a very, let's say, uh, troubled, uh, ecosystem geo-pol-- uh, geopolitical environment that is a bit shaky, and there is all this regional, uh, restriction that having here and there between US, EU and all these regions. 18:54 Do you think that providers 18:57 that are regional or regional providers of, uh, cloud services, I don't know, Hetzner, OVHcloud, all these, uh, that are very focused into Europe or they are in the, the US and not, not wanted that. 19:09 Do you think they have now, uh, a leverage of this private cloud to be able to use a cloud, uh, related system but in re- in a specific regions? What do you think about that? 19:23 Yeah, I mean, uh, like you rightfully said, that because it's such a volatile industry, such volatile, uh, uncertain geopolitical situation, uh, of course, there will be a need where businesses or even the government has to store the data in, in particular region, making sure there is no cross-region duplication as well. 19:41 I mean, with public cloud, it's so much easier, right? That you, you have data in one region, uh, but the data residency you could change. 19:48 Whereas with this private cloud, there's more assurance, uh, more assurance to consumers, more, more assurance even if it's, um, if it's a government data, then more assurance to the people of that particular region. 19:59 Uh, and, and that's, that's much more needed, and I would say that's a, that's a good change. 20:04 Um, and obviously they would, uh, the private cloud providers in this area where they are very focused on their, uh, geographic location and security of the data and limiting the data access on that particular region would, would definitely have some sort of upper hand. 20:21 They would definitely have some leverage. Um, at the same time, I would also feel that, uh, hyperscaler, uh, um, 20:30 AWS, Azure, GCP, they would definitely innovate on this, this, uh, area, uh, area as well, uh, uh, because they, they definitely see the market. 20:39 And, and one, uh, service, um, I would say like something like AWS Outpost, right? We have seen that coming in for a few years, and now a lot of people are using it. I mean, the reasons could be different. 20:50 The reason could be the faster data availability, the la- reducing latency, but at the same time, now the re- the, the reason for going for Outpost could be the residency of the data, the, the geographic location of data. 21:06 Yeah, indeed. 21:07 And, and also the initiatives such as, uh, the Sovereign Cloud that Azure, you know, has put up I think a, a week ago or something that, you know, has been very marketed across the, across the sectors and all, and all this stuff. 21:21 And, and also moving forward, and maybe I can start with Damian, and then I will ask you, uh, Nilofer. 21:28 You know, as Nilofer has said about TBM and the governance and all this stuff, uh, and mentioning cost centers, so, uh, that's something that will relate to tagging a bit. 21:38 Um, and will relate to, uh, being able to granularly obtain that data. 21:43 Do you think, Damian, that for TBM, uh, and FinOps, we can have a common point or an agreement to be using tagging on a- all these allocation, uh, strategies to be able to mark where the each of the costs should be allocated? 22:00 Do you think tagging can have a, a key role in, in here? 22:05 Um, I think that, well, of course, the more, the more, um, lower you can go, the more data you can get is the, you know, the, the better, you know, understanding you get from an environment. 22:18 I think that, uh, we touched a little bit about it before. I think that, uh, focus is a great opportunity right now to, to have these two worlds engage and, and learn one from it, from each other, right? 22:29 If one, while, while one, like Nilofer was saying, is more focused on the, you know, long term and on the business more value, the other one is in the day to day is how to optimize. And there, the, the... 22:42 When you have all the data and the more data that you have and the more, uh, lower and using tagging and using other te-techniques, um, you get all this data, and you have these two, uh, group of people working together. 22:56 I think the, the, the... Even the sky is not the limit, right? Uh, I guess that, uh, we, we will see many interesting things, uh, they're doing, uh, on, on different areas. 23:07 And, and, and again, FinOps, uh, is already looking into how, you know, uh, start visualizing at least part of the, what is going on in data center. It's looking into SaaS and, uh, license there. 23:23 Uh, um, I think it, that, that we have a future that is gonna be very interesting even on that. And, and, a-and again, I think that, uh, FinOps will gain also a, 23:34 a lot from understanding or looking more into the, you know, the business. And, and it's in a good position as well because it's always working with different teams. It's used to doing that. 23:43 So, so adding another team, it's not a problem. Good deal. And what do you think about it, Nilofer? 23:51 What do you think about this, uh, the cost allocation synergies between, uh, FinOps and, and TBM?See, any cost, um, regardless it is, uh, in the cloud infrastructure or in your data center has to be allocated, right? 24:05 It has to make some sense that, that w-at the end, uh, uh, which solution is it, um, uh, is it for or what, what's it... what that solution, uh, is bringing, which, which business unit is it supporting, right? 24:20 Which applications it's supporting, and then at the end of the day, uh, why we have to spend. That-that's regardless of any spend in, in any organization. 24:28 When it comes to IT, uh, I-IT related cost, when it's in cloud or in data center, um, it's... I, I guess it's say it's day one of, uh, knowing your cost, right? 24:40 Uh, and then after that you can make the decision whether is, is it, whether is it good cost or, uh, something you should take action on it, or is it in line with your business innovation or, uh, some cost that you are aware that probably it's not optimized, it's not making sense at, at this day in time, but it is in line of bringing new business in. 25:00 So it, it has to create some, uh, some sort of, um, meaning out of that cost, if it makes sense. 25:07 Now, tagging is one way, which is, um, uh, which something, uh, I think any FinOps practitioner would look at on their day one. That what's their, uh, tagging strategy, are you tagging it, uh, correctly? Um, 25:21 and, um, uh, and, and same thing for, for TBM, but which cost pool, uh, this cost is associated with, and then translating it to different solutioning tower and this, the different, uh, business tower. 25:33 So I would, I would say cost allocation, uh, regardless of TBM, FinOps, regardless of data center or cloud, uh, is, is day one of, uh, any IT business management practice. Good deal. Good deal. 25:49 And, you know, since we are talking about this, this cost allocation and now we are getting a bit into the more financial world. 25:55 So for people that are into, let's say, finance and more, let's say as a DA or management decision, um, how do you think they should leverage, uh, the TBM, uuuuh... 26:08 That, let's say that there are finance or management people in the financial world, and they don't know about TBM for whatever reason. 26:13 How do you think they should start, you know, uh, in the TBM ecosystem and leveraging the TBM, uh, framework for their practice and for their companies? Um, so I have... 26:27 I've studied TBM framework, and I, I've, I've, uh, used it for one of my customer, uuuh, some time ago. 26:34 Uh, in my experience, what I have seen is that generally finance leaders are, uh, in much more in, in line with the TBM framework because the way TBM framework is built, uh, the terminology, the taxonomy is very much in line with the finance audience. 26:53 It's, uh, rather than, um, contrary to the, the FinOps world, the cloud world, whereas the cloud terminology is more towards engineering focus, more towards the, uh, cloud architect focus, uh, rather than finance focus. 27:11 Um, so I, um, I, I think that that's something I published in my article as well that, um, uh, it's really important for finance people or the finance leader to understand the cloud terminology and to under- to, to have some familiarity of it. 27:26 I mean, I understand that it's two complete separate discipline, right? I mean, uh, cloud FinOps, cloud engineering and finance. Uh, but having... Now, having that sort of just appreciation of what exactly it means. 27:40 Like when sometimes when finance talk about certain terms, above the line, below the line, probably not all cloud engineer would be able to, to kind of understand that, that whether it's, uh, one off cost, whether it's, uh, ongoing expense or how do you allocate that to particular product line or how do you allocate that for your revenue or for your... 28:00 Is it like, uh, your cost of goods? So, uh, in, in... 28:04 That terminology is not common with cloud engineers, whereas when it comes to the different cost center, um, or different cost pool or entering the ledger entries and stuff like that, that's, that's not common with the cloud engineering. 28:18 So I would say that kind of marries in between and that brings to the very, uh, uh, real wider question here that, um, uh, given the IT spend and the IT has gained, uh, in general technology spend and technology- Mm-hmm. 28:33 -has gained a massive, um, upper hand in past twenty, twenty-five years. How do you marry these two disciplines, right? I mean, you need to... 28:42 At the same, you need to understand finance side, and you need to understand business. You need to understand, uh, cloud model as well. 28:49 Uh, so it's, it's a very interesting discipline, and I'm, I'm quite excited to see that what future holds here. Okay. 28:57 And, and talking about the future that, that you just mentioned is, uh, you know, one of the things that we've been talking about a lot is the AI, right? 29:05 And so for this case, um, people may be not familiar of, of the role of AI in the TBM practice. And how do you think, you know, the, the AI part evolving both in TBM and, and in FinOps from, from your perspective? Yeah. 29:22 That's a, that's a very, very interesting question, right? Because at the moment we are in the early stages of AI, like, uh, FinOps for AI. 29:30 Uh, and, uh, um, and from, from TBM perspective, because it's a very strategic decision for any organization to invest in AI, uh, it's, it's a very top-down, top-top-down, um, uh, I, I would say top-down structure here. 29:49 Uh, whereas your... 29:50 where in your business leaders has already made the decision to invest in AI, uh, and then you are allocating it, uh, or you're using it in different, uh, part of your business unit, different part of your solutions. 30:02 Now, the question comes in that what sort of, um, uh, cost you are incurring for that. Is it like fixed cost, uh, variable cost? Your, uh, uh, educating your employees cost. 30:12 It, it goes in the training, it goes in the, uh, even, um, uh, expanding your, uh, uh-FTEs, right? 30:19 Um, so that, so that way, um, I'm very interested to see that the, uh, how much, uh, investment goes in AI, as in the percentage of the total IT spend, because again, that, like, um, I was mentioning earlier, that TBM is, um, in two areas. 30:35 Running the business and, and the changing the business. So this part, the AI investment for TBM would come under the changing of business, under the business innovation and agility, uh, of businesses. Okay. 30:50 Uh, yeah- I think I would like to add to the, yeah, to the AI is that I, I feel like today the AI is like once the phone, right? 30:57 We have the cellular phone, like, uh, in the beginning, the company's giving you the phone, you know, for work. It's like kind of what happening today, right? 31:05 There are some places that say, "Okay, you need to go, uh, you have this, go play around." And, and yes, I agree with Nofar that the, you know, the AI is, you know, uh, it's in a very good... 31:15 It's at the be- It's new beginning, because now as everybody's starting to play with it, uh, we have AI for ages, but now it's like a new beginning, which, you know, you see it everywhere. Everybody talks about it. 31:27 And companies are thinking, "Okay, how do I integrate this in one to five years?" But, uh, what I would like to at least get our audience from this is that, you know, you don't need to wait for, 31:37 uh, for the, the company to do that for you. You know, you have it available. 31:41 You have different AI machines, and I think that anyone that learns how to, you know, uh, add it to your regular, regular task, will be more efficient a- at work, and, uh, and it will only benefit from it. 31:54 And, uh, and of course, don't trust everything that, uh, the AI tells you. Check it, uh, twice, but, [laughs] but if you use it smartly, it will help you. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, for sure. 32:05 And yeah, it's definitely, uh, an enhancing tool, and it's not something that it will replace. It will help you, uh, remove manual task and thing that could be done easier. 32:14 I, I'm seeing some information about, uh, the allocation and how it can help doing the allocation automatically. I wouldn't trust it that yet. 32:22 I think, uh, automation can help a lot, rather than, uh, leveraging the AI doing your allocation for you. Uh, it's a bit risky. Um, so definitely be careful about that. 32:34 And, you know, trying to, to wrap up, uh, here is about, you know, for someone that, uh, is starting with FinOps and maybe coming from a more, let's say, less, uh, technical perspective and want to know a bit about more FinOps or TBM, what are... 32:49 have been your advices that, you know, being here for, for, for, uh, some time now in the practice, what's the advice that you would say to, to people that are starting with, with it, both on either FinOps or, or TBM? 33:03 What's your advice? Okay, I can go first. So in terms of, um, uh, when you say advice, I understand that in terms of learning this disciplines, right? 33:11 And, and, uh, using it, uh, in your day-to-day job to make sure that, um, uh, um, you're getting maximum, uh, value out of it. 33:21 I, I would say that, um, uh, understand, uh, look at FinOps as in the perspective of, um, um, uh, the, the value rather than just looking at the instances running. I mean, yes, we need to rightsize. We need to automate. 33:36 We need to make sure that our commitments are, uh, uh, in line. 33:40 So, uh, explore, explore this more, uh, in terms of, uh, little bit, uh, business perspective of it, uh, because, uh, uh, don't limit FinOps just to cloud engineering side of it. 33:52 That's, that's one of the advice I would give to people who probably would want to, um, uh, want to start, uh, learning FinOps. And, uh, from TBM perspective, it's, um, it, it, it's very business focused. 34:07 It's, it's a new, new discipline. There are some TBM tools out there, or probably I think just one or two I would say in the market. Uh, but start doing TBM first with, uh, just with simple Excel. 34:19 Uh, it's, it's, uh, it's a, using the appropriate terms in your, in your business lines, whatever your businesses you are in or whatever your company, uh, terminology is, whether it's in your product line or your business unit. 34:33 Uh, but start doing TBM with the, the Excel first, and then move your way, uh, or, or move upwards, uh, uh, towards more complex analysis, going for Power BI and then probably then, uh, once you are more, um, advanced in the field, then, then look for the appropriate tooling if needed. 34:54 But I guess, uh, day one, I would definitely start, uh, or I started with an Excel, uh, and, and it helped me. No, it's... I think that's good advice. 35:03 I think starting somewhere in general in life, like taking action and, and starting somewhere, even though it's not the ideal result, is the, the best thing that you can do. 35:13 Uh, you take action w- with what you know, and then the perfect solution will come through with the iterations, let's say. So iterations are very important. 35:24 And yeah, that, that's a great advice, I would say, for, for people to start now and not study everything and wait till, uh, the perfect solution arrives, right? 35:33 It's, it's not something that we should be doing in general, um, and especially in TBM, where there is a lot of things to do. You need to start somewhere and then, [laughs] uh, you evolve, right? 35:44 Using the, using the practice. Uh, and, you know, Damien, do you have any, any comments or any, any things on that? No, I, I love the idea. I think that, you know, uh, 35:59 the advice of using Excel should be applied in anything, right? You wanna do something? Do an Excel. Pros and cons. [laughs] Yeah. 36:08 In the, uh, Excel, I think it's a starting- Any, any decision that you wanna make, start Excel. [laughs] If you need to... 36:14 If you need anything related to numbers, I think open a- an Excel or a Google Sheet is the first step. 36:19 Then you complex the solution, and then you use, uh, additional tools or code or anything that works with tabular data. Uh, but E- Excel is a very good, uh, starting point of, of anything, I would say. 36:33 And, and people should, you know... Even though it's not the definit- definitive solution for almost anything, um, for this, I think it's a, it's a very good starting point. 36:43 Um, so Nofar, uh, thanks a lot for bringing some light on, on the TBM perspective. 36:48 I think now people can, uh, reference this podcast to, uh, learn about it and apply it to, uh, to their business and a- actually understanding what's, what's going through. 36:58 Um, so it's, it was a pleasure, um, to, to have you here. And we'll put your, uh, your articles, uh, in the, in the description as well, so people can have more, uh, context about it. 37:11 And yeah, uh, thanks, thanks for coming by. Thank you so much. Thank you, Victor, for having me, and it's absolutely brilliant speaking with you. Thank you, Damien, uh, and hopefully speak to you very soon. Thank you. 37:23 Bye. Thank you very much, Nofar. We're definitely gonna do this again in the future after we see a little bit more, uh, integration between the FinOps and TBM. We definitely need to talk again. Fantastic. 37:33 Thank you very much, guys. Thank you, guys. Thank you. See you next time. Bye-bye. [outro music]